2024
Belmont
Bethune-Cookman
Gardner-Webb
LMU
North Dakota
Southeastern Louisiana
Tulane
Wyoming

2023
Chicago State
Fresno State
James Madison
Morgan State
New Mexico State
Northern Colorado
Radford
Southern Illinois

2022
Auburn
Bradley
Eastern Michigan
Liberty
Northwestern
Purdue Fort Wayne
Southern Miss
Winthrop

2021
Buffalo
Bucknell
Illinois State
Mercer
Middle Tennessee
Rider
Saint Louis
Stephen F. Austin

2020
(Played as the Space Coast Challenge in Melbourne, FL due to COVID-19)
Clemson
Liberty
Mississippi State
Purdue

2019
Boston University
Gardner-Webb
Northern Colorado
Northern Iowa
South Carolina
UT Martin
West Virginia
Wichita State

2018
Bradley
Jacksonville State
North Florida
Penn State
SMU
Southern Miss
Western Carolina
Wright State

2017
Binghamton
CSUN
Evansville
Fresno State
George Mason
Louisiana Tech
Montana State
SEMO

2016
Auburn
Georgia State
Eastern Kentucky
Idaho State
NJIT
Purdue
Texas Tech
Utah State

2015
Cleveland State
Houston Baptist
Illinois State
Maryland
Rhode Island
Rider
South Dakota State
TCU

2014
Elon
Liberty
Miami (Ohio)
Morgan State
North Florida
Northern Iowa
Northwestern
Virginia Tech

2013
Bowling Green
Georgia Southern
Old Dominion
Oral Roberts
Presbyterian
Saint Louis
West Virginia
Wisconsin

2012
DePaul
Austin Peay State
Gardner-Webb
Howard
Iowa
Western Carolina
Western Kentucky
Wichita State

2011
Hampton
Illinois
Illinois State
Lipscomb
Richmond
Rutgers
Sacred Heart
Southern Illinois-Edwardsville

2010
LaSalle
Missouri
Morgan State
North Florida
Prairie View A&M
Providence
Western Illinois
Wyoming

2009
Cleveland State
Florida A&M
Kentucky
Oral Roberts
Rider
Sam Houston State
Stanford
Virginia

2008
Central Arkansas
Citadel
Drake
Grambling State
Morehead State
New Mexico
South Dakota State
UCF
Vanderbilt
Virginia Commonwealth