2024
BYU
Idaho State
Iowa
Providence
Rhode Island
Rice
San Diego State
VCU
Vermont
Wisconsin

2023
Creighton
Georgia Tech
Green Bay
James Madison
Maryland
Michigan State
Montana State
New Mexico
UMass
Washington State

2022
Central Michigan
Florida State
Harvard
NC State
Northern Iowa
Oklahoma State
Purdue
Tulane
Vanderbilt
West Virginia

2021
Arizona State
Baylor
Fordham
Houston
Idaho State
Iowa* (Pulled out due to COVID-19)
Seton Hall
Toledo
UCF
USC

2020
Was not played due to the COVID-19 pandemic

2019
Creighton
Florida Gulf Coast
Missouri
New Mexico
North Carolina
Notre Dame
South Dakota State
South Florida
Temple
West Virginia

2018
DePaul
George Washington
Georgia Tech
Idaho State
Kansas State
Kennesaw State
Michigan State
NC State
Princeton
Syracuse

2017
Arizona State
Columbia
Green Bay
Indiana State
Marquette
Mississippi State
Montana
Oklahoma State
South Dakota
Tennessee

2016
Davidson
Idaho State
Iowa
James Madison
Northeastern
Purdue
Stanford
Toledo
UCLA
Wichita State

2015
Duke
Georgia Tech
High Point
Idaho
Iowa State
North Carolina State
Northern Iowa
Seton Hall
Texas State
UAB

2014
Charlotte
Florida State
Furman
Hartford
Montana
Princeton
Washington
Wake Forest

2013
Arizona State
Arkansas State
Boston College
Illinois
Iowa
North Carolina
North Carolina - Wilmington
USC

2012
November
‍Green Bay
James Madison
Minnesota
Missouri
Richmond
Wichita State

‍December
‍Creighton
Miami (OH)
Nevada
South Florida

2011
November
‍Chattanooga
Cincinnati
Drake
Hofstra
Idaho State
Kansas State
Marist
Purdue
South Dakota State
Tulane

‍December
‍Colorado State
Indiana
Michigan State
Pittsburgh

2010
November
‍Florida Gulf Coast
Hartford
Iowa
James Madison
Montana
Penn State
Purdue
Utah
Virginia Tech
Wisconsin Green-Bay

‍December
‍Alabama-Birmingham
Ball State
Illinois State
Nevada

2009
Arkansas
Cleveland State
Duke
Iona
Marquette
Western Kentucky

2008
November
‍Boston College
Eastern Michigan
Illinois
James Madison
Maryland
Montana
South Dakota State
TCU

‍December
‍Chattanooga
Connecticut
Florida State
Missouri State
Northern Colorado
San Francisco
Stephen F. Austin
Washington

2007‍
‍November
‍Arizona State
Iowa
Kansas State
Michigan State
Mississippi State
Northern Illinois
Oklahoma
Tulane
‍
‍December
‍Belmont
Illinois-Chicago
LSU
Miami
Oregon
South Florida
Southern Miss
Tulsa

2006‍
‍November
‍Bucknell
Drake
Marshall
Monmouth
Richmond

‍December
‍Bowling Green
Duke
East Carolina
Liberty
Pittsburgh
SMU
Texas Arlington

2005
‍Arizona State
Baylor
California
Marshall
Mississippi State
North Carolina
TCU